Mine worker sacked for alleged sexual harassment wins job back

Sunday 31 December, 2017 | By: Thomas Birkbeck

A Queensland mine worker who was sacked after a 19-year-old colleague accused him of touching her backside and making sexual comments has won his job back after the Fair Work Commission said there was insufficient evidence.

Get your FREE Sexual Harassment Policy today, valued at $67.00. Click here to go to CCIQ Books store and use the code POLICY100 on checkout

Mine technician Vincent Wilson was sacked from Anglo American Moranbah North Mine in May for allegedly breaching the company’s sexual harassment policy.

The woman made a series of unsubstantiated allegations against Mr Wilson in her exit interview, including that he deliberately “patted or squeezed” her backside while they were working in close quarters in a “man basket”. She also claimed he put her into a “bear hug” and said: “See, I’m stronger than you.”

In an affidavit, the woman alleged Mr Wilson “from time to time ... initiated conversations of a sexual nature with me or made sexual innuendos” that made her feel uncomfortable, including “implying that I should pull my pants down” when discussing her tattoos.

She also alleged that during a break one day, while she was talking to crew members about her relationship with her boyfriend, Mr Wilson said words to the effect of: “That’s okay, you can come and live with me and you won’t have to pay any rent so long as you like gardening and sex and helping around the house.”

Mr Wilson strongly denied the allegations in his response to his employer, describing them as “quite offensive”. “I did not touch [Person A] at any time, anywhere,” he wrote. “I did not make any comment about [Person A’s] sex life or ask her for any sexual favours.

“I am confused about why [Person A] would make such allegations about me. I recall that we had a good working relationship. “I have never had any person make such allegations against me before and I have always got along well with my workmates, whether they be male or female.”

He also argued the claims were raised nearly seven months after the incidents were alleged to have occurred and “should have been treated with a high degree of scepticism”.

Nevertheless, Anglo American said “on the balance of probabilities” it was satisfied that the allegations were substantiated. “Your conduct is unacceptable in the workplace,” the company said in his termination letter.

Mr Wilson took his case to Fair Work, which last week agreed his termination had been “harsh, unjust and unreasonable” as a “valid reason for dismissal was not made out”.

The Commission also heard evidence that Person A had herself made sexual comments while in the break room that made another employee uncomfortable, including, “It’s steak and head job night next Tuesday at my place” and, “How come it’s okay for my boyfriend to play with my arse, but when I play with his, he gets upset?”

In her decision, Fair Work Commissioner Paula Spencer found the woman provided conflicting statements under cross-examination. “Based on the evidence in regard to the allegations, there is not clear and cogent evidence on the relevant test to substantiate the conduct,” she said.

“In allegations of conduct of this nature, the onus of proof is on the Respondent to satisfy that the conduct occurred as alleged, on the balance of probabilities. The evidence of the Applicant and Person A was in direct contradiction, and has been carefully considered.

“For clarity, in the current environment of sexual harassment allegations, it is necessary to comment that nothing in this decision should be construed as condoning sexual harassment at a workplace in any way.

“Nor should it be interpreted as limiting the employment of females underground. When allegations of sexual harassment and other conduct are made, the Commission has an obligation to carefully assess the evidence and weigh such against the tests in [section 387] of the [Fair Work] Act.”

A spokeswoman for Anglo American said the decision was being reviewed. “Anglo American is committed to our company’s values, which includes ensuring our employees are treated with care and respect at our sites,” she said.

“We will continue to take action to address any behaviour inconsistent with our values, including where there has been bullying, harassment or other harm to our employees.”

This is an abridged copy of an article published by News.com.au on 13th December 2017

Post your comment


  • Help With Marketing Research Assignment 15/09/2018 8:34pm (37 days ago)

    This Is Really Great Work. Thank You For Sharing Such A Good And Useful Information Here In The Blog For Students.

  • Cold Fusion Homework Help 15/09/2018 4:58pm (38 days ago)

    This Is Really Great Work. Thank You For Sharing Such A Good And Useful Information Here In The Blog For Students.

  • best essay writing service 23/05/2018 7:22pm (5 months ago)

    I like this article. We can without much of a stretch comprehend this article in light of the fact that the writer did not utilize extreme and awful dialects and plainly indicates all the data about the topic. Some articles have not taking after the right composition arrange but rather here I got better approach for composing. I like the method for composing and the presenting. Keep sharing. I will share this article for my companions and partners.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments